Menu
Contact us
- 1-800-622-8708
- sales@stonetiledepot.com
- 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM EST
Contact us
The best flooring for rental property is the one that holds up between tenants and can be bought again in the same color when a unit turns over. For landlords, house flippers and property managers, this guide compares the two materials in the table below with listings built for that job: luxury vinyl plank for living areas and bedrooms, and porcelain tile for bathrooms, kitchens and entries. Each comes with real products, the specs that decide a rental floor and the trim that finishes it.
In short: a click-lock vinyl plank with a 20 mil or thicker wear layer for the main rooms (this guide's cutoff, the upper half of our 6 to 30 mil range), a glue-down plank whose listing names commercial spaces for corridors and shared areas, and porcelain listed for commercial floors in wet rooms. Our luxury vinyl plank collection holds every vinyl line below, and our multi-family tiles collect the porcelain picked for apartment buildings.
Engineered hardwood, which we also carry in our engineered hardwood collection, has a real wood top layer and suits higher-end units and flips where buyers ask for real wood; our guide to LVP vs engineered hardwood compares the two. We do not sell carpet or laminate, so they are not compared here. For the vinyl and porcelain below, the listing shows the specs that matter in a rental: surface wear is covered by the wear layer, water by the waterproof listing (22 of our 26 vinyl lines carry one on some or all colors), and traffic in porcelain by the commercial floor listing.
| Room | Pick from this guide | Listing fact behind it |
|---|---|---|
| Living room, bedrooms | Andover, Prescott or XL Studio click-lock | 20 to 30 mil wear layer |
| Kitchen | Andover, or Bamboo porcelain | Andover listings name kitchens and every color is listed waterproof |
| Bathroom | Tempest or Carrara Blanco porcelain, or Andover | Porcelain listed for shower walls; Andover listings name bathrooms |
| Entry, mudroom, porch | Bamboo, Tempest or Carrara Blanco porcelain | Listed for outdoor floors |
| Corridors, shared areas | Nove Reserve glue-down, or porcelain | Commercial-grade named on the Nove Reserve listing; porcelain listed for commercial floors |
| Stairs, doorways | Andover Abingdale trim | Stair nose 2.75 x 0.75, stair tread 12 x 1.25, T-molding 1.77 x 0.28, reducer 1.77 x 0.345 in |
Wear layer is in mil (thousandths of an inch). Thickness is the total plank thickness. Sizes are width by length in inches.
| Line | Build | Wear layer | Thickness | Size | Rental use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XL Studio | Click-lock rigid core | 30 mil | 0.35 in | 9 x 60 | Higher-end units, flips |
| Laurel Reserve | Click-lock | 22 mil | 0.31 in | 9 x 48 | Units, attached pad |
| Andover | Click-lock rigid core | 20 mil | 0.20 in | 7 x 48 | Units, full trim set |
| Prescott | Click-lock rigid core | 20 mil | 0.26 in | 7 x 48 | Units |
| Nove Reserve | Glue-down | 22 mil | 0.10 in | 9 x 48 | Corridors, shared areas |
| Wilmont | Glue-down | 20 mil | 0.08 to 0.10 in (glue-down range) | 7 x 48 | Corridors, shared areas |
| Kallum | Loose lay | 20 mil | 5 mm | 9 x 48 | Units, heavier flexible plank |
| Wood-look porcelain | Porcelain tile | n/a | on each listing | 8 x 48 | Bathrooms, kitchens, entries |
The wear layer is the clear top layer of a vinyl plank, above the printed wood image. It is what takes the foot traffic, the dragged chairs and the move-in and move-out days, and it is measured in mil, one thousandth of an inch. Our vinyl lines run from 6 mil to 30 mil. This guide uses 20 mil, the upper half of that range, as its cutoff for the main rooms of a rental; the listing of each line states its own figure.
XL Studio has our thickest wear layer, 30 mil, on a 0.35 inch click-lock plank 9 by 60 inches long, with a 7 mm core and a 2 mm attached pad listed. Swilcan is a brown wood look, and the long plank suits open living areas in a higher-end rental or a flip going on the market.
Laurel Reserve has a 22 mil wear layer on a 0.31 inch click-lock plank, 9 by 48 inches, listed with a 6 mm core and a 2 mm attached pad. Bayside Buff is a light beige wood look. Our full comparison of all 26 vinyl lines is in the guide to the best luxury vinyl plank flooring.
The three builds differ in how the planks hold together and how thick they are.


The details of each build, side by side, are in our guide to click-lock vs glue-down vinyl, and the water listings of every line are in our guide to waterproof vinyl plank flooring.
A property manager with many units gains from one floor color that can be bought again for every turnover. Some colors come in more than one build, which lets units and shared areas match. Akadia, for one, comes in five click-lock lines (Cyrus, Cyrus 2.0, XL Cyrus, Prescott and XL Prescott), two glue-down lines (Nove Plus and Nove Reserve) and the loose lay Kallum. A building can run click-lock Akadia in the units and glue-down Nove Reserve Akadia in the corridors, in the same color.
Prescott falls between the thin and thick click-lock lines, 0.26 inches with a 20 mil wear layer, in 7 by 48 inch planks and an XL 9 by 60 version. Braly is a reddish wood look. Wilmont is a glue-down line in 7 by 48 inch planks with a 20 mil wear layer, and Charcoal Oak is one of its colors.


Stairs, doorways and the edges of a room need trim, and in a rental, trim bought in the floor's own color can be reordered with it. Andover Abingdale, a brown wood look in a 7 by 48 inch click-lock plank with a 20 mil wear layer, comes with a full set of matching LVT moldings: flush and overlap stair nose, a 12 by 1.25 inch stair tread, T-molding, reducer, end cap and quarter round.


A T-molding joins two floors of the same height, such as vinyl in a bedroom meeting vinyl in a hall. A reducer steps down from a thicker floor to a thinner one. Stair nose finishes the front edge of a step. Our LVT stair nose, T-molding and LVT transitions hold the trim for every line, and our guide to vinyl stair nose and trim explains each profile.
Wet rooms and entries in a rental can take porcelain tile instead of vinyl. The porcelain below is listed for commercial interior floors as well as residential floors, and for outdoor floors, which covers a front entry, a mudroom or a covered porch.
Bamboo is a beige wood-look porcelain in 8 by 48 inch planks with a natural finish, a wood-look porcelain for a bathroom or kitchen next to vinyl in the living room. Tempest is a black matte porcelain in 12 by 24 inches, and Carrara Blanco a white marble-look porcelain in the same size with a natural matte finish.



Shared areas, lobbies and corridors in apartment buildings are covered in our guide to commercial floor tile.
In an apartment building, the floor of one unit is the ceiling of the next, and several of our click-lock lines list a pad for sound or comfort. Studio and Laurel Reserve list a 2 mm attached pad, the standard Laurel line a 1 mm pad, and Smithcliffs a 2 mm closed-cell pad for sound and comfort. Trecento vinyl tiles have a 1 mm backing listed for sound protection. Glue-down planks have no pad.
For a flip, the listing specs that show on a walk-through are plank size and color. XL Studio at 9 by 60 inches has fewer seams per room than a 7 by 48 inch plank, and its listing gives a 30 mil wear layer and a 2 mm attached pad. For a long-term landlord, the specs that matter are the ones that make reordering simple at each turnover: a line with matching trim in every color, and a color made in more than one build, like Akadia.
Builders, contractors, dealers and other trade buyers can join our Pros Club trade program. Members get trade pricing applied automatically at checkout when they are logged in, and a dedicated trade specialist for selection, quotes and project support. Applying is free and carries no commitment, and applications are reviewed within a couple of days.
Apply on our trade professionals page, and see what the program covers in our guide to the trade program for contractors and designers.
It is the maker's statement that the plank is not damaged by water, printed on each color's product page, and it rests on the core of the plank. It is separate from the wear layer. In this guide, every color of Studio, XL Studio and Andover carries it, while Wilmont, one of the glue-down lines named for commercial spaces, does not say waterproof on its listing.
No, the two are separate specs. Cyrus and Cyrus 2.0 are both 0.20 inches thick, with 12 and 20 mil wear layers. Nove Reserve is only 0.10 inches thick with a 22 mil wear layer, more than several click-lock lines twice its thickness.
By the listed piece weights, Kallum loose lay is about 1.8 pounds per square foot, and our glue-down planks are 0.7 to 0.9 pounds per square foot. For a 500 square foot unit, that is about 900 pounds of Kallum against roughly 350 to 450 pounds of glue-down plank.
It varies by line. Cyrus 2.0 has 17 colors, Kallum 12 and Andover 11, and the original Cyrus line has 32. A larger line gives more choice when units are redone in different colors; a single color repeated across units keeps reorders to one product.
Yes. A wood-look porcelain such as Bamboo in the bathroom can meet a wood-look vinyl in the hall, and a reducer or T-molding in the vinyl line's color finishes the doorway between them, depending on the height difference.
Your cart is empty.